MIT Says ChatGPT Improves Bad Writing, But At What Cost?
This Week In Writing, we explore how ChatGPT and Grammarly are making us all sound the same.
A recent MIT study revealed that ChatGPT turns bad writers into better ones. Which, ok. That's like saying spell check makes bad spellers better ones. But, we'll let MIT have their research.
I'm still torn on using AI for creative writing, but I'm finding that ChatGPT is more often part of my professional workflow. I often use the tool to summarize or clean up client briefs or to turn my interview notes into something legible. For these uses, ChatGPT is extremely helpful.
Ironically, much of what ChatGPT creates is flagged as incorrect by Grammarly (is this the first battle in the coming AI wars?). Sentences are often strangely arranged or unnecessarily compounded.
As more people are comfortable using AI tools (be it ChatGPT, Grammarly, autocomplete, or something else), do we all start sounding the same?
Like a river stone is worn down over time, AI-polished writing has a similar feel. It's all kind of... smooth.
I often read submissions for The Writing Cooperative that have this smooth feeling. Unless they explicitly disclose (which they don't), there's no real way for me to know if the piece was generated by AI. But when there isn't a unique voice or tone, my suspicion is raised.
AI doesn't really create anything with a unique voice. Sure, it will probably improve and get there. But, right now, it's all kind of dull.
Part of what makes writing so much fun is sharing your unique perspective with the world. Why polish it all away for the sake of correctness?
A Note About CTAs
It was brought to my attention that the email version of the previous issue that was sent from Substack contained a CTA to join Medium with my affiliate link. It's ironic because that issue talked about how I was glad Medium was doing away with the referral system and that, in general, CTAs are not my favorite thing.
I had no idea those CTAs were still added to the end of Substack emails since it's set in the system settings and not on the article. So, that's a big oops on my part, and hopefully, you found the irony as funny as I did. Thanks to Wendy for clueing me in.
If you'd like to break the Substack cycle, transfer your subscription to my website where the email sends as it's intended to be seen and Substack doesn’t take 10% of the price if you choose to support my writing.
Medium Day Is August 12
As I’m sure you’ve heard by now, Medium Day is coming! The 12-hour event will feature over 100 workshops, panels, Q&As, and discussions hosted by Medium writers. As a presenter, I saw the test run schedule, and the list is pretty impressive! Plus, not all sessions were on that pre-run schedule, so it will only grow.
My session is called The Write Stuff: Writing on Medium and The Writing Cooperative Q&A. It’s scheduled for 10:00 am EST on August 12. In it, I’ll share some general information about submitting to The Writing Cooperative — what I’m looking for in submissions, what is worthy of nomination, and what typically causes me to pass on an article. But I want to focus most of my time on your questions.
I set up a form to submit your questions ahead of time. I’ll use these to structure the Q&A time, and I’ll try to get to as many questions as possible. Having them beforehand will ensure they’re answered, but I’ll also take as many questions live as possible.
Pre-submit your questions to my Medium Day session, and don’t forget to register for Medium Day. It’s going to be a lot of fun.
Related Posts
Don’t Take My Word for It
• CraftThis Just In: Personalized recommendations are the new algorithms and the best way to build a true audience.
Why Make Anything if You Don’t Think It Will Be Great?
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we discuss greatness and how chasing it is a possible and noble goal.
Pay People Not Platforms
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we look at why Substack’s collapse is actually a good thing for paid newsletters.
Let's Make the Internet Personal Again
• Featured • PublishingThis Week In Writing, we look at the once-in-a-generation opportunity to create a new internet filled with fun and originality.
Raising the Bar at the Writing Cooperative
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we look at changes to our publication standards and what they mean for you.
Advent, Waiting, and the Year of Transitions
• LifeThis Week In Writing, we look back at the year that was and determine what it means for the year to come.
Refilling the Creativity Tank
• LifeThis Week In Writing, we discuss what happens when creativity finds other outlets.
Celebrate Giving Tuesday
• LifeThis Week In Writing, we take a quick break from our regularly scheduled programming to celebrate nonprofit organizations.
It’s Time We Discuss Medium
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we address the platform that has supported my writing for nearly a decade.
My First Year on Mastodon and the Future of Social Media
• Social MediaThis Week In Writing, we look back at how social media fractured and why it’s a good thing for us all.
The Economics of a Self-Hosted Newsletter
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we talk about what happens when you eliminate platforms and go after it on your own.
Trick or Treat?
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we talk about pen names and whether they make sense for writers.
A New Era Begins
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we explore the internet’s current metamorphosis and how you can be part of the revolution.
My History of Blogging
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we celebrate the blog, explore the pendulum of online writing, and double down on quality.
An Update on Spam Submissions
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we talk about spam submissions to The Writing Cooperative and look at some of your thoughts on being called AI.
Would You Want to Know if I Thought Your Writing Sounded Like AI
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we talk about submissions to The Writing Cooperative and how to avoid false accusations.
How I Feel About Engagement Numbers
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we discuss what engagement means and if I get discouraged by a perceived lack thereof. Plus, a look at the future (again).
My Writing Is About Building Community
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we highlight some of the people I’ve met writing online and answer some of your questions.
It’s Time for a Fresh Start
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we talk about new Apple products, home renovations, and changes to the newsletter.
Choose Your Own Design
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we explore the wonderful world of blogs, where writers truly get creative.
Expanding Universes Make Better Stories
• CultureThis Week In Writing, we look at how worldbuilding is an essential part of epic storytelling.
Your Questions Answered
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we recap a successful Medium Day and address some of the questions I didn’t have time to answer.
Saving Frequently Isn’t The Only Way To Backup Your Writing
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we take a hard lesson from the latest Twitter/X hijinks. Plus, we look at what “human writing” means.
MIT Says ChatGPT Improves Bad Writing, But At What Cost?
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore how ChatGPT and Grammarly are making us all sound the same.
Do CTAs Even Work Anymore?
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we explore the “necessary evil” of calls to action and ask if they are any better than tacky banner ads.
It’s Time to Rebel from Mass Market Social Media
• Featured • Social MediaThis Just In: IT is the villain in Silo. We should learn from those in the Down Deep and rise up.
Platforms Are Getting Much Worse
• PublishingThis Just In: Platforms want us to know exactly who controls the internet. It’s not us, but it can be!
Metrics Don’t Matter
• CraftHave we become so accustomed to seeing metrics everywhere that they no longer mean anything?
Why Make Anything if You Don’t Think It Will Be Great?
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we discuss greatness and how chasing it is a possible and noble goal.
Pay People Not Platforms
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we look at why Substack’s collapse is actually a good thing for paid newsletters.
My First Year on Mastodon and the Future of Social Media
• Social MediaThis Week In Writing, we look back at how social media fractured and why it’s a good thing for us all.
The Economics of a Self-Hosted Newsletter
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we talk about what happens when you eliminate platforms and go after it on your own.
My History of Blogging
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we celebrate the blog, explore the pendulum of online writing, and double down on quality.
How I Feel About Engagement Numbers
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we discuss what engagement means and if I get discouraged by a perceived lack thereof. Plus, a look at the future (again).
My Writing Is About Building Community
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we highlight some of the people I’ve met writing online and answer some of your questions.
It’s Time for a Fresh Start
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we talk about new Apple products, home renovations, and changes to the newsletter.
Your Questions Answered
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we recap a successful Medium Day and address some of the questions I didn’t have time to answer.
Saving Frequently Isn’t The Only Way To Backup Your Writing
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we take a hard lesson from the latest Twitter/X hijinks. Plus, we look at what “human writing” means.
MIT Says ChatGPT Improves Bad Writing, But At What Cost?
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore how ChatGPT and Grammarly are making us all sound the same.
AI Is Now Everywhere
• AIThis Week In Writing, we talk about Google’s new AI plan, what it means for writers, and why resistance is futile.
My Ghostly Strategy: Avoid the Graveyard
• PublishingThis Week In Writing, we fully explore how I’m building Ghost into a self-hosted content hub and how you can too.
Another Platform Collapses
• Social MediaThis Week In Writing, we talk about Reddit and what it means for centralized communities moving forward.
The Problem With Creative Entitlement
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore how AI tools amplify the sometimes problematic relationship between creator and consumer
This Just in Comes Home
• PublishingWelcome to the first issue of This Just In completely managed from my website!
BlueSky, Mastodon, and Notes; Oh, My!
• Social MediaThis Week In Writing, we talk about all the “Twitter Alternatives” and what makes the most sense for writers.
We Have to Talk About Platform Proliferation
• Social MediaThis Week In Writing, we ask why no platform is content on doing one thing well and instead want to do all things poorly.
On Tennis and Writing Breaks
• LifeThis Week In Writing, I discuss my prolonged break from daily writing and follow up on last week’s Substack article.
We Have to Talk About Substack
• Featured • PublishingThis Week In Writing, we talk about Diffusion of Innovation Theory and dying platforms.
The Era of Centralized Platforms Is Over
• Featured • PublishingThis Week In Writing, we discuss whether you should still own a website if you publish on Medium or Substack.
AI Is Not an All or Nothing Choice
• Featured • AIThis Just In: AI use isn't a moral binary. There's a practical middle path for writers.
Unchecked Writing
• AIThis Just In: I stopped using Grammarly; have you noticed? Plus, a deeper exploration into AI writing and my friend the em dash.
Want to Write a Novel in November?
• CraftThis Just In: NaNoWriMo may be dead, but writers have two new options to help hit those writing goals.
AI Exposes the Deeper Rifts in the Writing Industry
• AIThis Just In: Monetization turns passions into sweatshops and AI is making it worse.
AI Killed NaNoWriMo
• AIThis Just In: The writing month challenge may be dead, but there’s a new option to keep writers going.
A Few More Thoughts on Copyright
• AIThis Just In: The history of copyright might be fraught, but it exposes a bigger issue when creating online.
Copyright in the Age of AI
• AIThis Just In: What does copyright do and does it even matter anymore?
Is Reading Dying
• CraftThis Just In: AI summaries and the pivot to video are bad news for the written word.
Are Apple’s Writing Tools the Right Stuff
• AIThis Just In: Apple Intelligence offers the boring version of AI I’ve hoped for, but is it helpful for writers?
Hitting the Reset Button
• PublishingLLM scraping is a virus eating up the internet, but I’m done fighting. Instead, I choose open access and human connection.
Is Generative AI Destroying the Open Web
• AISubscription walls prevent AI scraping, but at what cost? I’m rethinking my whole publishing strategy.
Is Apple Intelligence the AI for the Rest of Us
• AIThis Just In: Apple’s forthcoming entry into AI promises a private, personalized AI, but will it increase AI slop?
Generative AI in Creativity
• AIThe reader survey results have some interesting things to say about generative AI and creativity. Here’s why that’s a problem.
What Is Your Freelance Writing Rate
• FreelancingWriting jobs are evaporating for many reasons, but freelance rates were really bad long before AI came around.
Can We Find a Balance With AI?
• AIThe dichotomy of AI continues to baffle me as I see the good and the bad. Where do we draw the line, and how do we learn to live with this technology?
Don’t Feed the AI Beast
• AIThis Just In: Justin’s writing requires a subscription to prevent AI abuse; consider your own precautions.
An Update on Spam Submissions
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we talk about spam submissions to The Writing Cooperative and look at some of your thoughts on being called AI.
Would You Want to Know if I Thought Your Writing Sounded Like AI
• EditorialThis Week In Writing, we talk about submissions to The Writing Cooperative and how to avoid false accusations.
Saving Frequently Isn’t The Only Way To Backup Your Writing
• CraftThis Week In Writing, we take a hard lesson from the latest Twitter/X hijinks. Plus, we look at what “human writing” means.
MIT Says ChatGPT Improves Bad Writing, But At What Cost?
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore how ChatGPT and Grammarly are making us all sound the same.
AI Is Now Everywhere
• AIThis Week In Writing, we talk about Google’s new AI plan, what it means for writers, and why resistance is futile.
The Problem With Creative Entitlement
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore how AI tools amplify the sometimes problematic relationship between creator and consumer
ChatGPT, the Writer’s Strike, and the Future of Content Writing
• AIThis Week In Writing, we explore a middle-of-the-road approach to ChatGPT and the future of writing
How I Use Midjourney to Create Featured Images for Articles
• AIGenerating unique and interesting featured images, you only need a Discord account and a little patience. Here’s how I use the tool.
Creative Burnout and Why I’m Pausing The Writing Cooperative After 12 Years
• Featured • EditorialAlysa Liu's story is relatable and the timing is impeccable.
What Bad Bunny Gets That NBC Doesn’t
• CultureThis Just In: NBC hosted the Olympics, the Super Bowl, and Bad Bunny’s halftime show on the same night, so why was their messaging so poor?
AI Is Not an All or Nothing Choice
• Featured • AIThis Just In: AI use isn't a moral binary. There's a practical middle path for writers.
It’s the End of the Year as We Know It (and I Feel Tired)
• LifeThis Just In: It’s time to look back at the year that was and set up some hopes and dreams for the year to come, or something like that.
Unchecked Writing
• AIThis Just In: I stopped using Grammarly; have you noticed? Plus, a deeper exploration into AI writing and my friend the em dash.
The Dream of EPCOT
• LifeThis Just In: Walt Disney’s community of tomorrow is a celebration of humanity and a prototype for how we should live. Maybe we should listen.
It’s Not All About the Benjamins
• PublishingThis Just In: Yet one more thing that Diddy was wrong about.
The Internet Was Doomed From the Start
• Featured • PublishingThis Just In: Maybe it’s time to rethink the entire internet.
Want to Write a Novel in November?
• CraftThis Just In: NaNoWriMo may be dead, but writers have two new options to help hit those writing goals.
Answers to a Few Questions
• CraftThis Just In: There were fewer questions than I anticipated, but I will answer them nonetheless.
What Questions Do You Have
• CraftThis Just In: I won’t be participating in Medium Day this year, but I still want to keep the spirit alive. Ask me anything.
What I Did Different With This Book
• PublishingThis Just In: Launching a second edition wasn’t as simple as I thought it’d be, and I learned some lessons along the way.
Introducing Write Now’s Revised Second Edition!
• Featured • PublishingThis Just In: You can now access everything I’ve learned writing online over the last two-plus decades. Are you ready for it?
Can We Talk About Comments?
• PublishingThis Just In: Hearing from readers is a lot of fun until you start to get spammed with bots and AI nonsense farming for attention.
Let’s Talk About Tools
• TechThis Just In: There’s no single tool that can do everything and it’s extremely frustrating.
Battle of the Book Builders
• TechThis Just In: I tried to format my book using Vellum and Atticus. Instead, I learned something about app design and limitations.
Does My Journal Need a Backup
• TechThis Just In: I took a lot of your suggestions to heart and gave Obsidian a try. What I found was a bigger question.
Journals Aren’t Forever
• TechThis Just In: After over 13 years, I’ve deleted the Day One journal app. Here’s what it helped me realize about software subscriptions.
This One Has No Direction
• BurnoutThis Just In: Tried, drained, and a little burnt out isn’t exactly the best time to focus on your writing, but it’s why you do it anyway.
AI Exposes the Deeper Rifts in the Writing Industry
• AIThis Just In: Monetization turns passions into sweatshops and AI is making it worse.
The Cost of Rebellion
• Featured • Social MediaThis Just In: Rebellions are built on hope, but they require individual sacrifices for collective improvement.
Abuse of Power Comes for Nonprofits
• LifeThis Just In: Wikipedia’s 501(c)(3) tax exemption is threatened, but not by the IRS.
How to Move to Ghost In 2025
• PublishingThis Just In: Own your own publication by launching a website running Ghost. It’s not as difficult as it sounds.
Creative Burnout and Why I’m Pausing The Writing Cooperative After 12 Years
• Featured • EditorialAlysa Liu's story is relatable and the timing is impeccable.
What Bad Bunny Gets That NBC Doesn’t
• CultureThis Just In: NBC hosted the Olympics, the Super Bowl, and Bad Bunny’s halftime show on the same night, so why was their messaging so poor?
AI Is Not an All or Nothing Choice
• Featured • AIThis Just In: AI use isn't a moral binary. There's a practical middle path for writers.
It’s the End of the Year as We Know It (and I Feel Tired)
• LifeThis Just In: It’s time to look back at the year that was and set up some hopes and dreams for the year to come, or something like that.
Unchecked Writing
• AIThis Just In: I stopped using Grammarly; have you noticed? Plus, a deeper exploration into AI writing and my friend the em dash.
It’s Not All About the Benjamins
• PublishingThis Just In: Yet one more thing that Diddy was wrong about.
Want to Write a Novel in November?
• CraftThis Just In: NaNoWriMo may be dead, but writers have two new options to help hit those writing goals.
Answers to a Few Questions
• CraftThis Just In: There were fewer questions than I anticipated, but I will answer them nonetheless.
What Questions Do You Have
• CraftThis Just In: I won’t be participating in Medium Day this year, but I still want to keep the spirit alive. Ask me anything.
What I Did Different With This Book
• PublishingThis Just In: Launching a second edition wasn’t as simple as I thought it’d be, and I learned some lessons along the way.
Introducing Write Now’s Revised Second Edition!
• Featured • PublishingThis Just In: You can now access everything I’ve learned writing online over the last two-plus decades. Are you ready for it?
Let’s Talk About Tools
• TechThis Just In: There’s no single tool that can do everything and it’s extremely frustrating.
Battle of the Book Builders
• TechThis Just In: I tried to format my book using Vellum and Atticus. Instead, I learned something about app design and limitations.
Does My Journal Need a Backup
• TechThis Just In: I took a lot of your suggestions to heart and gave Obsidian a try. What I found was a bigger question.
Journals Aren’t Forever
• TechThis Just In: After over 13 years, I’ve deleted the Day One journal app. Here’s what it helped me realize about software subscriptions.
AI Exposes the Deeper Rifts in the Writing Industry
• AIThis Just In: Monetization turns passions into sweatshops and AI is making it worse.
AI Killed NaNoWriMo
• AIThis Just In: The writing month challenge may be dead, but there’s a new option to keep writers going.
A Few More Thoughts on Copyright
• AIThis Just In: The history of copyright might be fraught, but it exposes a bigger issue when creating online.
Copyright in the Age of AI
• AIThis Just In: What does copyright do and does it even matter anymore?
The Forthcoming First Amendment Fight
• CraftThis Just In: So-called defenders of free speech are taking office, and we’re all in trouble. Plus, more predictions for 2025.
Is Reading Dying
• CraftThis Just In: AI summaries and the pivot to video are bad news for the written word.
Are Apple’s Writing Tools the Right Stuff
• AIThis Just In: Apple Intelligence offers the boring version of AI I’ve hoped for, but is it helpful for writers?
This One’s for the Fans
• CultureThis Just In: Jimmy Buffet gets the due he deserves and shows what creative passion is all about.
When Creating Stops Being Fun
• CraftThis Just In: knowing when (and how) to hit delete is important for every creator’s sanity.
When Gamification Goes Awry
• TechWriting days, health rings, Duolingo… there are more streaks than time.